DESPITE BAN, NEW YORK CITY YOUTH HELD IN SOLITARY
In July 2018, the New York Times reported that New York City still sends youth from Rikers to state prisons. Despite New York City’s ban on solitary confinement for youth younger than 22-years-old, these state correctional facilities, which have no such limitations, have held several youth in solitary confinement. In fact, the number of youth transferred from Rikers to state facilities has recently increased, suggesting that the transfer practice is being used to circumvent the restriction on solitary confinement.
- Read more: DOJ Investigation on Solitary at Rikers (2014)
NYC MAYOR & INDEPENDENT COMMISSION: CLOSE RIKERS
On March 31, 2017, New York City Mayor Bill De Blasio pledged to close Rikers Island, the infamous jail where Kalief Browder was incarcerated for three years, and convert New York City’s prison system into a several smaller, local jails. TIME: The Kalief Browder Story, a documentary series shown on Spike TV during March and April 2017, documents the hell that the then sixteen year old endured in Rikers – beatings by guards, attacks by other youth, and 800 days of solitary confinement. Read coverage by the New York Times.
Mayor De Blasio’s announcement came just days before the release of a report by an independent commission created last year by City Council to study mass incarceration in New York. “Towards a More Just NYC: Independent Commission on New York Criminal Justice and Incarceration Reform,” recommends closing Rikers, which it describes as a stain on the city and a “ball of darkness” that takes a “particularly heavy toll on adolescents, women, and those with mental health issues.” The report acknowledges almost all of the abusive conditions and practices captured by TIME’s filmmakers, describing Kalief’s story as “a powerful rallying cry for those interested in forging a more just and humane justice system.” The commission recommends creating several “state-of-the-art facilities located closer to where the courts are operated in civic centers in each borough.” The report lays out a plan to phase out the use of Rikers over several years while the city creates five community jails with clustered housing, improved programing, and staff training. While these changes will cost New York City upwards on $10 billion to implement, their net impact will reduce costs, eventually saving the city $1.6 billion per year.
The report also makes key recommendations to reform the city’s justice system, many of which focus specifically on youth ages 16-24:
- Reduce incarceration through diversion, crime prevention, and better mental health services;
- Reduce pre-trial detention by using pre-trial supervision, risk assessment tools, and ending money bail;
- Reduce case processing delays in the courts and ensuring procedural justice; and
- Reform sentencing with alternatives to incarceration, raising the age, and reducing racial disparities.
The commission recommends many of the same strategies used by effective juvenile justice facilities to create safe, rehabilitative, and human conditions inside jails and to eliminate abusive practices like solitary confinement.
For more information on Rikers, visit CloseRikers.org.
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE INVESTIGATION OF RIKERS ISLAND
Rikers has long been the focus of investigation for abuse and corruption. In 2014, the Department of Justice completed an investigation of Rikers, criticizing the Department of Correction for using extreme violence and excessive solitary confinement against adolescents at Rikers Island.
- Read more about the DOJ investigation on Rikers (2014)